How does a player trend up? If Scott Rolen was only qualified enough to earn 10% of the votes in year 1, how does he suddenly earn 75% in year 6? If he was good enough in his first year of eligibility, he should be elected. One of the truly incredible mysteries of our time.
Scott Rolen made the Hall of Fame But Dale Murphy's Still Not Good Enough?
How does a player trend up? If Scott Rolen was only qualified enough to earn 10% of the votes in year 1, how does he suddenly earn 75% in year 6? If he was good enough in his first year of eligibility, he should be elected. One of the truly incredible mysteries of our time.